Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Veal Parmigiana
Zeppoles (6)
Cauliflower Crust Personal (10 Inch)
Grandma Pizza
About
NICKY G'S PIZZA
Welcome to Nicky G's Pizza, a delightful establishment nestled in the heart of Pompton Lakes, NJ, at 4 Colfax Ave. If you're on the hunt for an exceptional pizza experience in North Jersey, look no further. Nicky G's has earned its reputation as a beloved local eatery, consistently delivering quality food and a warm, welcoming atmosphere.
The standout feature here is, without a doubt, the pizza. Customers rave about the crispy crust that serves as the perfect base for fresh ingredients. Whether you're craving a classic slice or want to indulge in a grandma pie bursting with basil and mozzarella, Nicky G's caters to every palate. The unique toppings and daily specials keep the menu exciting, ensuring there's always something new to savor.
But pizza isn't the only star of the show. The garlic knots are legendary, as highlighted by numerous delighted patrons. Soft, chewy, and generously infused with a garlic olive oil buttery sauce, these knots are a must-try and elevate the dining experience. Reviewers like Cal Delano and Jessica C. can't stop singing their praises, claiming they are the best around.
Moreover, Nicky G's prides itself on a commitment to quality. As Charles Olivera mentions, every dish is made to order, ensuring you’re served nothing less than fresh and flavorful. This attention to detail is complemented by the personable staff, who not only customize orders but also contribute significantly to the community, making every visit feel special.
For those with a sweet tooth, don’t skip the zeppoles! Angela Miranda calls them amazing and rightly so, as they offer a superb finish to your meal.
In essence, Nicky G's Pizza is more than just a place to grab a slice; it's a cozy retreat that brings together fantastic food and exceptional service. Whether you’re dining in or opting for takeout, you can expect a satisfying culinary journey. So, next time you're craving the essence of a Brooklyn slice or some garlic knots that will haunt your dreams in the best possible way, head over to Nicky G's Pizza. You won’t be disappointed!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Nicky G’s has the best garlic knots around. If you like soft chewy seasoned garlic knots in a garlic olive oil buttery sauce you will love these. Knot for those who like the hard stuff dry type Portions are always great and price is reasonable. Great local place to get take out. Enjoy! ”
“ My favorite pizza in North Jersey! They have the BEST garlic knots I’ve ever had in my life too! Thanks Nicky G’s! ”
“ Great place to get excellent food. All dishes are made to order, never will you get leftover or reheated food Also Nick is a great person. Customizes any order Contributes greatly to the community. ”
“ Best pizza around! The guys behind the counter are nice too! Their zeppoles are amazing!! Pizza is the closest I’ve had to a Brooklyn slice since I moved to Jersey a few years ago! Love this little place! ”
“ Nicky G's is an absolute gem! From the moment you walk in, the inviting atmosphere sets the perfect tone for a great meal. The pizza is outstanding—crispy crust, fresh ingredients, and a perfect balance of flavors. The grandma is a must-try, bursting with basil and mozzarella goodness. The staff is friendly and attentive, making you feel right at home. Plus, their unique toppings and daily specials keep me coming back for more. If you're looking for delicious pizza and a warm vibe, Nicky G's is the place to be! Highly recommend! ”
“ Search and ye shall find! Ever since moving to Pompton Lakes I’ve been searching for the best pizza around me and I’ve tried a bunch to much disappointment. Either the sauce isn’t right, the crust is too soft/hard or the cheese is just right. But Nicky’s hits the nail on the head and knocks it out of the park. I ordered a large extra cheese and it came to only 16.65 and I gotta say I eat almost the whole pie to myself every time I order. The balance of everything is just perfect and if you love pizza then this is the place for you! ”
“ This place is located in downtown and its small restaurant with big taste. I've gotten some hot wings and pizza and it was good. The hot wings where hot idk if they have different levels. But tasty and pizza was full of flavor and nice crispy crust. ”
“ Buffalo wings, tuna wrap on whole wheat, plain pie (asked for it well done) Everything was perfect! My boyfriend and his friends wanted wings and a pie, I wanted to eat something a little more substantial, I'm happy the tuna wrap was an option! The tuna wrap was delicious and flavorful. The wings were nice and spicy. The pizza was definitely impressive, asking for it cooked well done made the bottom crusty perfectly crunchy. Yummy! ”